El Deafo

El Deafo is an awesome graphic no20701984vel ideal for kids 9-12 but that could appeal to a wider audience.

The story of a young girl who loses her hearing is worthy of book club discussion and could help broach the topic of disability in a lesson on inclusion.

The substance doesn’t make it boring for casual readers. There’s enough humour and emotion to keep readers connected to Cece.

The way the illustrations handle vision loss is perfect and the hearing loss reflected in empty dialogue bubbles and jumbled text is extremely clever.

Fantastic story with adorable illustration.


aprilThe LumberJanes is a strange but fun graphic novel suited for tweens.

The girls in the comic are quirky, diverse, and have hilarious one liners like “I have many skills. Falling is among them.” They make fairy tale references as they battle mysterious wildlife and often exclaim the names of famous women where there would normally be an “oh my God”. A lot of the references might be lost on kids but they are amusing for readers who recognize the names.

Why are hipster Yetis so odd?

Because they can’t even.

The graphic novel is broken lumberjanes1-e1406304295769down into chapters based on the badges the girls earn as LumberJanes.

While it has the pace and interest level appropriate for ages 10-13 the girls do use words like “jerk”, “stupid” and “what the junk” in place of swears and I know some parents might object to it.

It’s off the wall and has no real explanation in Vol. 1 for why there are 3 eyed beasts and possessed boy-scouts…but if you like fun stories about adventurous girls this is worth a look.

Ms. Marvel Vol. 1

20898019I heard great things about Ms. Marvel and it lived up to the hype.

G. Willow Wilson  writes some of the best character development I’ve seen in a graphic novel.

This is a perfect comic for a book club because it opens up discussion about subtle prejudice, feminism, body image, religion and more. Even though it ties into the Marvel Universe readers don’t have to be familiar with previous comics to follow the story- it serves as an introduction.

I think this is particularly important in my community right now where I’m hearing a lot of negativity about Muslim refugees. The main character is a young Muslim girl with a strict but caring family. She wants to find a way to fit in while maintaining her culture and it is challenging for her to find acceptance.

I have already ordered Vol. 2 and look forward to reading it.


193510431A fantasy adventure with a dark sarcastic sense of humour. Starring anti-heroes this graphic novel will appeal to grown up fans of Megamind and Despicable Me. Teens who like a sympathetic villain character and supernatural powers will love Nimona.

It is refreshing to see a female character who is empowered but imperfect. She’s a feisty monster. Not hero or a damsel in distress but her own thing.

It’s a weird but wonderful read.

The Plain Janes

313162The Plain Janes by Cecil Castellucci and Jim Rugg is an exciting graphic novel geared mostly towards teen girls.

Rebellion, art and friendship are explored through the familiar “new girl” trope but go beyond typical high school drama. The story is framed by a terror attack. Jane’s character evolves because of the trauma.

I thought the mother’s overprotective anxieties were realistically smothering and anxiety inducing for Jane. Jane’s obsession reminiscent of  While You Were Sleeping    makes sense given her need to connect with someone who shared her experience.

A quick, enjoyable read for teens looking for realistic fiction in graphic novel format.

American Born Chinese

118944American Born Chinese is a graphic novel by Gene Luen Yang. It mixes a contemporary story with Chinese folklore (the Monkey King).

It is an interesting take on racism focusing on a young man who is embarrassed of his heritage, family and friends. Jin feels like he needs to be more white to attract the girl he likes.

I enjoyed the story and I think it will appeal to ages 12-15. Colourful and imaginative illustrations grab reader’s attention but it’s also a story with heart.

This book has won many awards and I think it could work for a graphic novel book club.


Friends With Boys

11389398I was hooked by this graphic novel in the beginning. A contemporary story about a nerdy girl who can see ghosts has so much potential. I am always looking for graphic novels or comics that can appeal to young teens and/or have well written female characters.

Unfortunately I found this one to be too didactic. It was clearly from an adult’s perspective and felt like a story a parent would tell a child not an authentic young person’s voice.

I liked the art and there were elements I enjoyed but I feel like if I use them with my teen book club I might be too obviously teaching a lesson.  Maybe it would be better in a school setting, to discuss bullying or peer pressure. It just didn’t quite make it for me as something  most teens would fully enjoy in their free time.

We Were Liars

16143347 E. Lockhart weaves breathtaking imagery throughout We Were Liars. The way she words heartbreak, loss and physical pain is exactly what I’ve tried to do a thousand times through poetry but I have never managed to be so succinct and descriptive.

The descriptions of chronic illness and migraines rings true to me as a reader who has experienced these things.

Teens will connect with the angst and attraction between Cadence and Gat. I think the closeness of the cousins when they are together contrasted with their lack of communication the rest of the year will especially resonate with older teens who have gone away to college or university and have a similar relationship with friends back “home”.

The fairy tales Cady makes up are fantastic little allegories for what’s going on in the story.

There are surprising twists to this novel that will haunt readers and keep it on their mind long after they finish reading.

The Paper Sword

cover artRobert Priest’s novel The Paper Sword is a high fantasy. Like many high fantasies it has unique character names that are cool but impossible to pronounce, and sometimes difficult to keep track of.  It is written in formal, descriptive but distant narration, which I think is a shame because I prefer to get in a character’s head.

The maturity of the plot does not mesh well with the level of vocabulary. Preteens would find the text too dense but older teens would not care for the content.

This book just didn’t work for me. I had to force myself to keep reading. The writing style is too dry for my taste.